Showing posts with label TNMM. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TNMM. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 May 2014

Gist of latest important tax caselaws / judgements



Below are the recent important tax caselaws related to Income tax, Service tax, Excise in brief. The citation is made available for your benefit :
INCOME TAX


SECTION 9
INCOME – DEEMED TO ACCRUE OR ARISE IN INDIA
The assessee, an event management company, engaged the services of a non-resident agent to bring the foreign Artists to India. The assessee paid remuneration to the Artists and commission to the agent. It deducted tax on the amounts paid to the Artists but did not deduct tax on the commission paid to the agents. - Sum paid to agent could not be deemed to have arisen from the personal activities in a contracting State in status of entertainer or athlete - Commission paid to the agent was not hit by Article 18(2) of India-UK DTAA, and, therefore, income arising to agent couldn't be said to be taxable in India - Director of Income-tax (International Taxation) v. Wizcraft International Entertainment (P.) Ltd. (2014) 45 taxmann.com 24 (Bombay)
 
 
SECTION 92C
TRANSFER PRICING - COMPUTATION OF ARM’S LENGTH PRICE
Comparables and adjustments/TNMM: Where in transfer pricing proceedings, TPO made adjustment to assessee's ALP in respect of software development services, in view of fact that two comparables selected by TPO were improper on account of very high turnover, impugned adjustment was to be set aside and, matter was to be remanded back for disposal afresh - Adaptec (India) (P.) Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax (2014) 44 taxmann.com 236 (Hyderabad - Trib.)
 
 
 
SERVICE TAX
SECTION 65(27)
TAXABLE SERVICES - COMMERCIAL TRAINING OR COACHING SERVICES
Prior to 27-2-2010, definition of 'vocational training institute' nowhere mandates that institute must be recognized or accredited; therefore, export import management and retail management and merchandising activities are exempt from service tax even if courses are not approved/affiliated - Commissioner of Service Tax, Delhi v. Ashu Exports (P.) Ltd. (2014) 44 taxmann.com 113 (Delhi)
 
 
 
CENTRAL EXCISE ACT
SECTION 35G
APPEALS - MAINTAINABILITY OF
Question 'whether assessee can avail of SSI-exemption simultaneous with Cenvat credit in respect of goods' relates to interpretation of exemption notification and 'rate of duty' and not appealable before High Court - Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai v. BD Industries (2014) 44 taxmann.com 75 (Bombay)
 
 SECTION 35K
APPEALS - BINDING NATURE OF PRECEDENTS
Where revenue had initiated coercive recovery during pendency of stay application of assessee, said proceedings were quashed and contempt proceedings against revenue were dropped after unconditional apology - Fashion Suitings (P.) Ltd. v. Superintendent, Central Excise & Service Tax (2014) 44 taxmann.com 84 (Rajasthan)
 


Saturday, 22 February 2014

Recent Important judgements on Transfer Pricing

DCIT vs. Panasonic AVC Networks India Co Ltd (ITAT Delhi)

Transfer Pricing: Adjustment to profit margin for “capacity underutilization” can be made. In choosing comparables, there cannot be a cherry picking for deciding parameters of rejection. All comparables must face the same test


Under Rule 10B (1)(e)(ii), an adjustment to the net profit margin has to be made for “capacity underutilization”. Capacity underutilization by enterprises is an important factor affecting net profit margin in the open market because lower capacity utilization results in higher per unit costs, which, in turn, results in lower profits. Of course, the fundamental issue, so far as acceptability of such adjustments is concerned, is reasonable accuracy embedded in the mechanism for such adjustments, and as long as such an adjustment mechanism can be found, no objection can be taken to the adjustment. On facts, the CIT(A)’s approach is reasonable and the adjustments are on a conceptually sound basis

DCIT vs. Air Liquide Engineering India (ITAT Hyderabad)

Transfer Pricing: TPO cannot sit in judgement on commercial expediency. RBI approval means the payment is at ALP. If overall TNMM analysis done, royalty cannot be analyzed separately


The TPO is not entitled to sit on judgment on the business and commercial expediency of the assessee in paying royalty to its’ parent company as per the provisions of the Act as laid down clearly by the Delhi High Court in EKL Appliances 345 ITR 241. It is also noted that various Tribunals such as DCIT vs. Sona Okegawa Precision Forgings (ITA No. 5386/Del/2010), Hero Motocorp (ITA No 5130/Del/2010), ThyssenKrupp Industries (ITA No 6460/Mum/2012), Abhishek Auto Industries (ITA No 1433/Del/2009) have taken a view that RBI approval of the Royalty rates itself implies that the payments are at Arm’s Length and hence no further adjustment needs to be made viewed from this angle too. Furthermore, we are of the opinion that once TNMM has been applied to the assessee company’s transaction, it covers under its ambit the Royalty transactions in question too and hence separate analysis and consequent deletion of the Royalty payments by the TPO seems erroneous. We draw support from Cadbury India (ITA No 7408/Mum/2010 and ITA No.7641/Mum/2010 wherein the ITAT upheld the use of TNMM for Royalty

Tilda Riceland Pvt Ltd vs. ACIT (ITAT Delhi)

Transfer Pricing: No bar on reliance of private database u/R 10D(3). Nuances of the CUP Method under Rule 10B(1)(a)(i) explained


(i) Rule 10 D(3) is only illustrative in nature and merely describes the information required to be maintained by the assessee under section 92D “shall be supported by authentic documents, which may include the following …”. The logic employed by the Transfer Pricing Officer that since databases compiled by private entities is not included in rule 10D (3), such databases cannot be relied upon by the assessee is clearly fallacious inasmuch as an item not being included in illustrative list of required documents does not take outside the ambit of ‘acceptable document’ for the required purposes. In any event, all that Tips Software does is to collect the data, compile the same in easy to refer format and make it available to the end-user of such data online. The data is public data maintained by the customs department at various ports. It was also open to the TPO to, if he had any doubts, call for further information from this database supplier and examine authenticity of the data so furnished. His summary rejection of the data as unreliable on a technical ground is not tenable in law

Lummus Technology Heat Transfer BV vs. DCIT (ITAT Delhi)

Transfer Pricing: Unaudited segmental accounts can be relied upon for comparing profitability of controlled transactions with uncontrolled transactions. While size is relevant in entity level comparison, it is not relevant in transaction level comparison within the same entity


(i) In applying the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) under Rule 10B(1)(e) it is not necessary that the net profit computations, in the case of internal comparables (i.e. assessee’s transactions with independent enterprise), have to be based on the audited books of accounts or the books of accounts regularly maintained by the assessee. All that is necessary for the purpose of computing arm’s length price, under TNMM on the basis of internal comparables, is computation of net profit margin, subject to comparability adjustments affecting net profit margin of uncontrolled transactions, on the same parameters for the transactions with AEs as well as Non AEs, i.e. independent enterprises, and as long as the net profits earned from the controlled transactions are the same or higher than the net profits earned on uncontrolled transactions, no ALP adjustments are warranted. It is not at all necessary that such a computation should be based on segmental accounts in the books of accounts regularly maintained by the assessee and subjected to audit
Source:Itatonline