Everything you want to know about Swachh Bharat Cess (SBC)
The
Hon’ble Finance Minister Shri Arun Jaitley while presenting Union Budget for the
year 2015-16 on 28th February, 2015 had introduced a new cess to be
named as Swachh Bharat Cess to be levied and collected on taxable services. Unfortunately,
the manner in which the legislation has been introduced, it has created mess
out of cess and is prone to lots of litigations. If the government is serious
about ‘ease of doing business, then it must immediately issue clarification on
various issues. The objective of this article is to identify various
issues/queries relating to Swachh Bharat Cess (SBC) and try to clarify the same
in simple language in FAQ format.
Kindly note that
subsequent to writing of this article by the author, the Central Government has
issued Notification No. 23, 24 and 25/2015-ST dated 12-11-2015 and has
clarified some of the issues raised in this article.
1. What is Swachh Bharat Cess (SBC)?
An
enabling provision was incorporated in the Finance Act, 2015 vide Chapter VI to
empower the Central Government to impose a Swachh Bharat Cess on ALL or ANY of
the taxable services at a rate of 2% on the value of such taxable services. Section
119(2), which is the charging section of the Act, is reproduced below:-
“(2) There shall be levied and
collected in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter, a cess to be
called the Swachh Bharat Cess, AS SERVICE TAX on all or any
of the taxable services at the rate of two per cent on the VALUE of
such services for the purposes of financing and promoting Swachh Bharat
initiatives or for any other purpose relating thereto.”
Thus,
the objective of the levy is to finance and promote the Swachh Bharat
initiatives of the Central Government, which is a dream project of Prime
Minister Shri Narendra Modi. Undoubtedly, the objective of CLEAN INDIA is holy
and pious and needs to be supported by every Indian. The cleanness is directly
associated with hygiene and health of the residents and promotes international
image of the nation.
Note: Exactly same
point has been answered similarly at Q1 and Q4 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
2. Whether SBC is chargeable on import or
manufacture of goods, like done earlier for Education Cesses?
No,
SBC is not chargeable on goods. Unlike education cesses, the levy has been subjected
only on taxable services. The rationale behind the differentiation between
goods and services is not known, especially when dirt, pollution and
environmental damages are mainly attributed to manufacturing activity,
industrialization and relatively more directly related with goods than
services. Hence, the levy is not based on principles of equality and the
service sector has been discriminated and penalized for no fault of theirs.
Yet, the parliament is constitutionally empowered to legislate and enforce the
same.
3. What is the date of implementation of
SBC?
The
Central Government was empowered under sub-section (1) of Section 119 of the
Finance Act, 2015 to appoint a date for the implementation of SBC. The Central
Government has issued Notification No. 21/2015-ST dated 06-11-2015 to implement
SBC from November 15, 2015.
The reason for implementation during festive season and from the middle of the
month is unknown especially when the government could have appointed the date
anytime after 14th May, 2015 when the Act received the assent of the
President of India.
Note: Exactly same
point has been answered similarly at Q2 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
4. Ok,
so w.e.f. 15-11-2015, Swachh Bharat Cess @ 2% should be charged extra in the
invoice?
As clearly evident from Section 119(2) as quoted
above, the levy of SBC is @ 2% only. However, The Central Government has issued
another Notification No. 22/2015-ST dated 06-11-2015 whereby it has exempted
from payment of SBC calculated in excess of 0.50%. Therefore, the effective rate
of SBC is 0.50% and not 2% due to exemption of 1.50% granted by the government.
Note: Similar point
has been answered similarly at Q9 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
5. A ‘Cess’
is a ‘tax on tax’. Do we need to calculate SBC @ 0.50% on the amount of service
tax like we were earlier doing for calculating Education Cess and SHE Cess?
No,
unlike surcharge, which is a ‘tax on tax’, every cess need not necessarily be a
‘tax on tax’. In the Indian context, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in a ruling in
Shinde Brothers Vs. Commissioner, Raichur reported in 1967, said that ‘‘the
word cess means a tax and is generally used when the levy is for some special
administrative expense’’ citing various examples suggesting the name of the
cess explains the object. Thus, cess is a tax which can be collected in any
manner but to be utilized only for purposes specified at the time of levy.
The
new provision, as quoted above at point 1, clearly says that the levy of SBC
shall be @ 2% on the VALUE of such services. So, unlike education
cesses, which were levied not on value of services but on service tax thereon,
SBC is not a tax on service tax. Thus, SBC @ 0.50% should be calculated on the
same value upon which service tax is calculated.
Note: Similar point
has been answered similarly at Q10 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
6. What would be the effective rate of
service tax w.e.f. 15-11-15?
The
effective rate of service tax, including SBC, w.e.f. 15-11-2015 would be
14.50%. However, for some services, where Valuation Rules or Abatement is applicable,
the effective rate is less than 14.50% as tabulated at Point 11.
7. Whether SBC is levied on all or
selected services?
The
Central Government was empowered to impose the new levy on either all the
taxable services or on few services. According to some media reports, it was
expected that the government may impose SBC @ 2% only on few services which are
contributing maximum share of service tax (like telecommunication services).
However, the Central Government has not specified any particular service(s)
which are chargeable to SBC. The taxable services, except below as notified
vide Notification No. 22/2015-ST dated 06-11-2015 are leviable to SBC:
(i)
Services
covered under Negative List u/s 66D
(ii)
Services
exempt from ‘service tax’ under any notification issued u/s 93(1) of the
Finance Act, 1994
In
other words, the following types of services are not chargeable to SBC:-
(i)
Services
excluded from the definition of service as per Section 65B (44) like services
provided by an employee to the employer, etc.
(ii)
Services
provided or deemed to be provided outside the ‘taxable territory’. It means SBC
is not chargeable even on services provided in the state of J&K as it is
Non-Taxable Territory.
(iii)
Services
exempted under Mega Exemption Notification No. 25/2012-ST.
(iv)
Services
abated under Notification No. 26/2012-ST to the extent of abatement.
(v)
Services
exempted under Notification No. 33/2012-ST to the extent of threshold of Rs. 10
Lacs.
(vi)
Services
provided to SEZ exempted under Notification No. 12/2013-ST
In
simple words, if a person is liable to pay service tax, he becomes liable to
pay SBC @ 0.50% on the same value upon which service tax is calculated @ 14%.
In
view of the author, since the levy is on ‘taxable service’ and services covered
under negative list are ‘non-taxable service’, the above notification exempting
negative list services is clarificatory in nature and even in the absence of
such exemption, the levy was never on those services.
One cannot exempt something which was never taxable.
Note: Exactly same
point has been answered similarly at Q11 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
8. What is the significance of the phrase
“all or any of the taxable service” used in the charging section 119(2)?
Covered
separately in article titled ‘Whether the Levy of SBC is challengeable? Yes, it
seems to be...’
9. Whether SBC needs to be charged
separately in invoice, like education cesses?
NO!!
Upon strict interpretation of law, there is no need to charge, collect, account
or pay SBC independent of service tax. The entire tax can be charged and paid @
14.50%. The plain reading of the charging section states that SBC shall be
levied and collected ‘as service tax’. The bifurcation of service tax and SBC
can be easily done at the end of the department. In fact, CBEC has not yet
notified separate accounting code for SBC.
Having
said that, to avoid unnecessary disputes, it is advisable to charge SBC separately
after service tax as a different line item in invoice. It can be accounted and
treated similarly to Education cesses. If distinct accounting code is not
notified, it can be paid in the main code and if distinct accounting code is
notified, it shall be paid in newly notified code.
Note: The point has
been answered differently at Q7 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
Also, at Q8, the FAQ has provided the accounting code for SBC as follows:
Swachh Bharat Cess
(Minor Head)
|
Tax Collection
|
Other Receipts
|
Penalties
|
Deduct Refunds
|
0044-00-506
|
00441493
|
00441494
|
00441496
|
00441495
|
10. Whether reverse charge is applicable
on SBC?
Yes,
if a person is liable to pay service tax under reverse charge, then SBC shall
also be paid under reverse charge, because the levy is on ‘taxable value’ and
not on the person liable to pay service tax. In case of reverse charge u/s
68(2), the liability has been simply shifted from service provider to service
receiver without any change in gross tax liability. Also, according to section
119(5) of the Finance Act, 2015, the provisions of Chapter V and the rules made
thereunder are applicable to SBC. Thus reverse charge created u/s 68(2) which
is a provision under Chapter V is made applicable to SBC. The service tax and
SBC shall be treated equally for all practical purposes as they are one and
same. By use of the words, ‘as service tax’ in the charging section
itself, the legislation has made it abundantly clear that SBC is nothing but
service tax with the only difference that the proceeds shall be used only for
Swachh Bharat initiatives.
Note: Similar point
has been answered similarly at Q12 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
11. What is the effective rate of service tax on
services subject to abatement or valuation rules?
Note: The effective
rate as tabulated above is summarised form of answers provided at Q13, Q16 and
Q17 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
12. The moot question is whether Cenvat
Credit is available on SBC?
Most of the subject experts are of the view that
since SBC is not specifically covered under Rule 3 of Cenvat Credit Rule, 2004,
cenvat credit is unavailable, unless Rule 3 is amended to this effect. With due
respect, the author differs in opinion and is of the view that cenvat credit
can be availed on SBC. However, unless the government clarifies the issue and
allow cenvat credit, the same would be subject to litigation. The issue
requires detailed analysis and may be taken up in subsequent write-up.
Note: This point has
been answered differently at Q14 of FAQ issued by CBEC on 14-11-2015.
As clarified by CBEC, the SBC
is not integrated in the Cenvat Credit Chain. Therefore, credit of SBC cannot
be availed. Further, SBC cannot be paid by utilizing credit of any other duty
or tax. The FAQ issued by CBEC can be downloaded from: http://www.cbec.gov.in/resources//htdocs-cbec/press-release/faq-sbc.pdf
***
Address : Ganpati
Campus, Lal Building Road, Rourkela – 769012, ODISHA
Contact :
+91-9937041788
